Is buying a hot water heater really cheaper than renting?

Is buying a hot water heater really cheaper than renting?

Buying a hot water heater vs. renting one has been an ongoing debate for homeowners for many years, and the answer may surprise you. 

Renting a hot water heater in Ontario costs roughly between $15-$55 a month. The benefit of a rented system is that should it break down, you don’t have to worry about maintenance or replacement costs because those costs are covered by the owning company (whoever you are renting from).  However, this rental fee is ongoing for as long as you rent the hot water heater, and if you ever want to replace it with a new one, you may incur significant rental cost fee increases based on the new unit. These can be a substantially greater cost. 

Installing a hot water heater will typically cost between $800-$1200 plus installation costs of roughly $300-400.  While there is an upfront cost, the major benefit of owning a hot water heater is that once the system is purchased and installed you own it outright – no ongoing monthly rental fee commitments.  Since a typical hot water heater usually lasts anywhere from 10-15 years, if you amortize the purchase price vs rental fees, an owned system typically pays for itself in approximately 6-8 years (barring major repairs).  After the hot water system has been paid off there are no other ongoing monetary commitments, so costs in the long run are typically lower for a purchased vs. a rented system.

It should be noted that there are times when renting makes more sense; however, if you’re going to be staying in your home for a significant period, consider installing and owning your hot water heater – it has the potential to save you a considerable amount of money.

Contact Waterloo Energy Products, we are always happy to help!

CALL WATERLOO ENERGY at (519) 648-9977


 #HotWater #HotWaterHeater #WaterlooEnergy #RentVsBuy #WaterlooEnergyProducts



Pricing was competitive and the great referral were the deciding factors. Every one of the people at the job site were courteous and respectful.

Cindy and Bian Coughlin, Newmarket, ON

Great service! Hard working! Developed an amazing Geothermal project for our new build. Highly recommended.

Joseph Puopolo

The last HVAC Company we used for maintenance services was a hard seller and very annoying. They were always trying to upsell us on a new energy efficient furnace and air purification system. I could not handle their desperation for sales so we decided to look for a new company to deal with. After reading some great reviews, I contacted Waterloo Energy. We needed our spring service done on our HVAC unit; we hired them for a trial run. They came out the next day and I was very impressed with them. I will say that they offer a five star service at a reasonable price. You always get what you pay for. The thing we liked best is they did not try to sell us on their first visit. The technician was knowledgeable, dependable, polite and kept us informed of everything. Highly recommended!

Damien White

Read More Testimonials


Subscribe to the Waterloo Energy Products Newsletter

Get Important News,Rebates, Information & Insights: